What is the Eastwood Rule?


Clint Eastwood may have had this expression when he found out the Eastwood Rule was named after his unyielding desire to have his way.
Clint Eastwood may have had this expression when he found out the Eastwood Rule was named after his unyielding desire to have his way.
© Bettmann/CORBIS

"Avatar" without James Cameron. "E.T." without Spielberg. "Citizen Kane" without Orson Welles. What would some of history's greatest films have been like without their legendary directors? One could argue that these movies may have turned out completely differently if they were directed by someone else -- if they were even made at all.

The director is the creative driving force behind a movie. His job is to turn words on a page into images on a screen, to tell a story rich with imagery and to create films that will evoke emotions and deeper thought.

All of this movie-making magic doesn't just start when the director yells, "action!" It begins months, even years before at the start of pre-production. Before the director sets foot on a film set, he devotes tremendous time and energy to casting, storyboards, scouting out locations and planning every shot to help bring his vision to life. Once production begins, the director's job gets even more intense, as many directors work around-the-clock to film and wrap a movie.

But what if a director dedicates his time and energy to a movie, only to be unceremoniously fired before the film ever hits the screen? Not only would he suffer a creative loss but a financial one as well. Even worse, someone else would likely get credit for directing the film.

While directors once had relatively little protection against this kind of scenario, the Eastwood Rule, introduced in the 1970s, was designed to change that. Want to know how it helps protect a director's interests in a film? Keep reading to find out.

Ditching the Director? Think Again.

It's kind of ironic that Clint Eastwood is now winning awards from the same institution that fought to limit his power.
It's kind of ironic that Clint Eastwood is now winning awards from the same institution that fought to limit his power.
© PHIL McCARTEN/Reuters/Corbis

Like many in the entertainment industry, directors are represented by a union -- the Directors Guild of America. The DGA maintains a strict set of guidelines aimed at protecting the financial and creative rights of its members. One of these guidelines, casually referred to as the Eastwood Rule, is designed to prevent anyone from firing a director once he's been hired and begun work on a movie.

Specifically, the Eastwood Rule stipulates that no actor, producer or other person engaged in a film may fire the film's director and assume his duties and title. For example, a producer who disagrees with the director on the direction in which a film is heading can't simply dismiss the director from the project and take on the job. Along the same vein, a star, no matter how well-known, can't have the director of a film fired and replaced with another member of the crew [source: McGilligan].

The Eastwood Rule goes into effect once any film crew hires a director who's a member of DGA and signs the organization's standard contract. Violations of the Eastwood Rule come with some pretty significant penalties, including hefty fines levied against the production and certain crew members. In some cases, the Directors Guild may even revoke the membership of whoever steps in to replace a canned director, making it difficult or impossible for that person to find work in the mainstream movie business.

This rule sends a message to moviemakers that a director puts plenty of work into a picture, including significant resources before filming even begins. It ensures directors will be paid for their work and helps manage egos and prevent disagreements.

Now that you know how the Eastwood Rule works, let's take a look at where it got its name and the events that inspired its creation.

Don't Mess With Clint

Because of the Eastwood Rule, it's now harder for filmmakers and actors to fire directors, even if there are "creative differences."
Because of the Eastwood Rule, it's now harder for filmmakers and actors to fire directors, even if there are "creative differences."
© TASS/ITAR-TASS Photo/Corbis

As you may have guessed, the Eastwood Rule is named for legendary actor and director Clint Eastwood. But the use of his name isn't a tribute -- if anything, it's a dig at Eastwood and his refusal to let anything get in the way of his vision as he films a movie.

In 1976, during the filming of "The Outlaw Josey Wales," Eastwood grew increasingly frustrated with director Philip Kaufman's slow, methodical style and unwavering desire to create the perfect shot, no matter how much time it took. Shortly after filming began, Eastwood used his star power to have Kaufman kicked off of the project. After he convinced producers to send Kaufman packing, Eastwood took over the director's chair for the remainder of the project.

The problem was that Kaufman -- who went on to direct "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" and "The Unbearable Lightness of Being" -- had not only put a great deal of work into pre-production and filming but also co-wrote the script for the movie. The Directors Guild fought hard for Kaufman's reinstatement, but Eastwood refused to budge. Determined to prevent other directors from suffering a similar fate, the Guild beefed up penalties for letting go of a director once he'd been hired, and the Eastwood Rule was born.

Ironically, Eastwood's actions would come back to spite him. When writer and director Richard Tuggle failed to meet Eastwood's expectations during work on the movie "Tightrope" in 1984, the Eastwood Rule prevented him from having Tuggle removed from the project. Eastwood did take over many of the directing duties for the project, but Tuggle still got the title and stayed involved with the movie till the bitter end [source: Denby].

Related Articles

Sources

  • Avery, Kevin. "Conversations With Clint: Paul Nelson's Lost Interviews With Clint Eastwood." Continuum International Publishing Group. 2011.
  • Barra, Allen. "As a Director, I've Never Had Star Power." The Wall Street Journal. May 22, 2012. (Aug. 22, 2014) http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702304019404577418600585837454
  • Denby, David. "Out of the West." The New Yorker. March 8, 2010. (Aug. 22, 2014) http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/03/08/out-of-the-west-6?currentPage=all
  • Directors Guild of America. "Basic Agreement." 2011. (Aug. 22, 2014) http://www.dga.org/Contracts/~/link.aspx?_id=7D5BFF125CE044E6B049F7E2B1A4FD70&_z=z
  • Kapsis, Robert E. and Kathie Coblentz. "Clint Eastwood: Interviews, Revised and Updated." University Press of Mississippi. 2013.
  • McGilligan, Patrick. "Clint: The Life and Legend." St. Martin's Press. 1999.