Have you ever heard a brand new song on the radio and realized that it sounds familiar? It's not really a cover of an old song, but perhaps it used a well-known bass line and repackaged it into a new arrangement -- much like Sean Kingston's 2007 "Beautiful Girls" borrowed from Ben E. King's 1961 classic, "Stand by Me." Another famous example is how Vanilla Ice borrowed the bass line from Queen and David Bowie's "Under Pressure" for his hip hop song, "Ice Ice Baby."
Or maybe it's more subtle than that. A modern hit song could have taken a 6-second drum sample from a lesser-known, 40-year-old funk recording. Indeed, this is the case for literally thousands of songs, mostly from the hip hop and rap genres, which have borrowed the drum break from 1969's "Amen Brother," a B-side song from a group called the Winstons. Another one of the most sampled pieces is the drum break from James Brown's 1970 song, "Funky Drummer."
This kind of musical borrowing is known as sampling. We should note that the term "sampling" can also refer to the process of turning music into digital data. In this article, we'll be talking about sampling as the process of incorporating a track from a previously recorded song into a brand new song.
But it's usually not just a matter of recording a drum break and simply plopping it into another song. It'll often involve taking a portion of the drum break -- even just a few slaps of the snare drum -- and looping it, or repeating the sampled section over and over to form a "loop." For instance, LL Cool J looped a section of the drums from "Funky Drummer" throughout his 1990 song, "Mama Said Knock You Out." Talented artists can sample more than one song at once. That same LL Cool J song, for instance, also happens to sample several other tracks, including a loop of background vocals from 1967's "Trip to Your Heart" by Sly and the Family Stone. Sampling can also involve creative manipulations, such as changing the speed or pitch of the original sample.
Few deny that it takes talent to sample a classic song effectively and use it in a new, creative way. And the practice has played a major role in shaping the entire genre of hip hop. But sampling has had a longer history and more complex legal implications than many people realize. Read about the process on the next page.
History and Evolution of Music Sampling
The roots of music sampling predate the 1980s, when the hip hop scene first emerged. Some point to the fact that jazz musicians have always borrowed each other’s riffs. But the sampling of recorded music evolved out of sound collage that started decades earlier. Early sound pioneers experimented with the very definition of music. Pierre Schaeffer and Pierre Henry, for example, started their own movement of musique concrète when they began collaborating back in the 1940s. Before tape recorders were even around, they used disc cutters to push the boundaries of music by making unique sound collages. And by “sound,” we mean more than just instruments. They also used the sounds of trains and mechanical noises. Soon, other pioneers such as Karlheinz Stockhausen were influenced by Shaeffer. And later, even the Beatles dabbled in musique concrète with their experimental track “Revolution 9” from "The White Album."
In 1961, James Tenney took it one step further by taking an existing popular song and drastically manipulating it. His "Collage #1" took Elvis Presley's recording of "Blue Suede Shoes," clipped out portions, rearranged them and played with the tempo. A more mainstream, but less experimental and avant-garde, example of collage came from Dickie Goodman and Bill Buchanan in 1956. Their "Flying Saucer" was a playful mashup of rock and roll hits from the era along with a fake news report about aliens landing from outer space. This and other Goodman and Buchanan releases became popular, attracting some of the first copyright lawsuits related to sampling.
It was not until the late 1970s and early 80s that sampling really exploded with hip hop. This began when DJs started interacting with and manipulating the vinyl records they played. At first, it became popular to play and replay the breaks in funk music, simply because crowds loved to dance to these parts. Kool DJ Herc is credited with originating this practice, and others, like DJ Grandmaster Flash, helped perfect the techniques, such as changing turntable speeds and turning the records manually. He joined other rappers to form Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five, and the group rose to national stardom with the 1980 single, "Freedom," which sampled "Get Up and Dance" by the rock band Freedom.
Hip hop and rap have relied heavily on the practice of sampling ever since, but you'll occasionally find examples of sampling in other genres. But legal issues have largely stifled its widespread use.
Music Sampling Legal Issues
Early on, hip hop artists could get away with sampling songs without repercussion. The artists generally didn't even seek permission from copyright owners, let alone receive permission. Soon, you could even buy CDs that contained compilations of drum and bass samples, including infamous breaks like the one from "Amen Brother," to create your own remixes. But as the genre grew in popularity and sales, copyright owners began to take notice of artists like Public Enemy, who used sampling heavily.
At first, the costs of a buyout, or the purchase of rights to sample a song, were modest. But these soon grew, and there were also additional fees called rollover rates, which added to the costs depending on how many units were sold. What complicates matters is that artists had to pay two different copyright holders for the same song: the copyright owner of the music (the composition) and the copyright owner of the actual recording. Artists can at least avoid paying the latter by making a new recording of the song. But members of Public Enemy claim that they had to change the group's sound as a result of restrictive copyright rules.
The general consensus is that these artists didn't sample older recordings to maliciously pass someone else's work off as their own, but to create something new with it. But despite harmless intentions and the value of the art they were creating, in the eyes of many, they were nevertheless profiting off of stolen work. For instance, Clyde Stubblefield, the original "Funky Drummer," still hasn't received compensation for his much-sampled drumming.
Now, copyright owners are more likely to clamp down on unauthorized sampling quickly. In 2004, Danger Mouse sent out promotional copies of his work called "The Grey Album," which was a mashup of the music from the Beatles' "The White Album" and Jay-Z's raps from "The Black Album." EMI, the label that owns the Beatles' recordings, quickly slapped Danger Mouse with a cease and desist order, preventing him from releasing the album commercially. (This didn't stop the album from becoming a huge hit over the Internet, however, as the work spread quickly over P2P networks.)
What bothers many supporters of hip hop sampling is that those suing for damages are usually not the original artists themselves, but the corporations that own the copyrights. One notorious case came in 2005, when Bridgeport, a one-man company that had acquired many copyrights, sued Jay-Z for his use of sampling. The Sixth Circuit court ruled in favor of Bridgeport and warned simply: "Get a license or do not sample" [source: Wu].
How Music Sampling Works: Author's Note
Having grown up during the height of hip hop, it was fascinating to learn more about the history and evolution of sampling. I’ll admit I’ve always been more partial to the soul and funk genres that hip hop artists were sampling than to the hip hop genre itself, and it’s easy to understand hip hop’s desire to incorporate those older classics. If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, sampling could be considered a form of worship. But the questions of copyright and ethics inevitably plague the topic of sampling. Despite the facts that hip hop artists might have good intentions and ultimately create a unique sound that is drastically different from the original sampled song, sampling is a sticky legal issue. On the one hand, it’s easy to sympathize with the argument that the original artists deserve recognition and compensation. But it’s harder to accept that argument when it turns out that compensation from the lawsuits often goes to non-artists who happen to hold the copyright. There seems to be no easy answer.
- Arkeny, Jason. "Grandmaster Flash." AllMusic.com. http://www.allmusic.com/artist/grandmaster-flash-p76452/biography
- Collins, Nick. "Introduction to Computer Music." John Wiley and Sons, 2010. http://books.google.com/books?id=mCpqmESEOEcC
- Dilberto, John. "Pierre Shaeffer & Pierre Henry: Pioneers in Sampling." June 14, 2005. http://emusician.com/em_spotlight/Pioneers_Sampling/
- Fitzpatrick, Rob, Mark Roland. "Gods of Rock." Sterling Publsihing Company, Inc., 2006. http://books.google.com/books?id=tQoLAKS8IJYC
- Harrison, Nate. "Can I Get an Amen?" nkhstudio.com. 2004. (June 22, 2011) http://nkhstudio.com/pages/popup_amen.html
- Howard, George. "Understanding Sampling, Cover Songs & Derivative Work." The Center for Music and Arts Entrepreneurship. Jan. 19, 2011. (June 22, 2011) http://www.cfmae.org/understanding-sampling-cover-songs-derivative-work/
- Kurutz, Steve. "Kool DJ Herc." AllMusic.com. http://www.allmusic.com/artist/kool-dj-herc-p312125
- McLeod, Kembrew. "How Copyright Law Changed Hip Hop." Stay Free! Magazine. AlterNet. June 1, 2004 http://www.alternet.org/story/18830/how_copyright_law_changed_hip_hop
- NPR. "Digital Music Sampling: Creativity or Criminality?" National Public Radio. Jan. 28, 2011. (June 22, 2011) http://www.npr.org/2011/01/28/133306353/Digital-Music-Sampling-Creativity-Or-Criminality
- Rhodes, Carl, Robert Ian Westwood. "Critical Representations of Work and Organization in Popular Culture." Psychology Press, 2008. http://books.google.com/books?id=wnbbY5hwCCUC
- Shachtman, Noah. "Copyright Enters a Gray Area." Wired. Feb. 14, 2004. (June 22, 2011) http://www.wired.com/entertainment/music/news/2004/02/62276
- Sisario, Ben. "Living Legend Tries to Make a Living." New York Times. March 29, 2011. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/30/arts/music/clyde-stubblefield-a-drummer-aims-for-royalties.html?_r=1&adxnnl=1&adxnnlx=1308787504-8uHHPXA2TRSTqK1mrY0Zug
Music Sampling: Cheat Sheet
Stuff you need to know:
- Music sampling is the process of lifting a section, such as a drum beat, from a song and including it in a new song.
- The evolution of hip hop and rap in the 1980 and ‘90s relied heavily on sampling, often taking samples from soul and funk music of the ‘60s and ‘70s and looping them so they repeat over and over.
- The roots of sampling pre-date hip hop, however, and originated in experimental music of the 1940s and ‘50s.
- As sampling grew in popularity, the copyright laws soon caught up, making it increasingly difficult and expensive to sample music.