How Board Breaking Works


Unarmed? Try training in hand-to-board combat.
Unarmed? Try training in hand-to-board combat.
Ryan McVay/The Image Bank/Getty Images

On the island of Bawean in ancient Indonesia, so the story goes, a woman named Rama Sukana was washing clothes in a brook when she noticed monkeys fighting in the trees nearby. Fascinated, she took careful note of their combat techniques and began practicing them herself.

Honing her sparring methods took time, and she ended up getting home much later than anticipated. Her husband was pacing back and forth waiting for his dinner and was too crazed with hunger and indignation to listen to her explanation. Instead he attacked.

Advertisement

Rama Sukana immediately went into monkey combat mode and neutralized him. In fact, she neutralized him so often that he eventually got tired of attacking her and asked if she could train him in the new technique of hand-to-hand combat that she'd invented. Thus was borne the Indonesian martial art known as pentjak silat [source: Blackbelt Magazine].

In Japan, in the 16th and 17th centuries, the government was worried about armed uprisings and decided the logical thing to do was to confiscate all weaponry. However rebellious they might be, peasants wouldn't dare confront blade-wielding Samurai with their bare hands. But the peasants had other things to worry about. Now that they were disarmed, how were they supposed to protect themselves from thievish bandits? Their answer was karate, which means "empty hand" [source: Biryukov].

Perhaps it's no accident then that these are the legendary origins of two of the martial arts most closely associated with the practice known in Japanese as "tameshiwari," the miraculous-looking feat of breaking boards, bricks and concrete slabs with bare hands. Borne of the need to defend against domestic abuse and lawless violence, pentjak silat and karate were designed to tip the scales in favor of the vulnerable. In asymmetric fighting, the weaker combatants must use unusual methods to defend themselves. Tameshiwari provides an astonishing demonstration of how such methods can result in the practitioner wielding seemingly impossible power.

Why chop wood with bare hands when we have axes for that?

In 2014, Maeve Murray, 11 at the time, was able to break two wooden boards in the karate class at Girls Up, a summer camp founded by her mother.
In 2014, Maeve Murray, 11 at the time, was able to break two wooden boards in the karate class at Girls Up, a summer camp founded by her mother.
Yue Wu/The Washington Post via Getty Images

Say a person has been training in a martial arts technique for some time and is reaching a level of high proficiency. We'll call her Jane. Say Jane leaves the training studio one day after practice and heads home. But when she turns a corner, a bunch of thugs jump her.

Thanks to her training, Jane's muscles react instinctively before she has time to be scared. She twists out of the grasp of Thug 1 and spins, landing a devastating kick on the side of his knee, which bends inward with a sickening crunch as he collapses. Thug 2 charges. Instead of running, Jane engages, closing the distance between them as she slips sideways and up, redirecting his attack with her shoulder and simultaneously breaking his nose with her elbow.

Advertisement

Thug 1 can't walk and Thug 2 is on the ground covered in the blood gushing from his nose. Both are screaming with pain. As Jane stands over her vanquished foes, adrenaline surging through her, she hears applause. Her teacher emerges from the shadows and confers a black belt on her as other students cart away the bloodied and broken "thugs."

Needless to say, the above is total fiction. Yet, the scenario described is exactly the sort of thing martial arts training is designed to help people face, and staging an unexpected attack on a student would, in some ways, be an ideal way to test her level of competence. However, as we can see, such a testing methodology has some inherent flaws (e.g., potential long-term damage to body parts). Aside from liability issues, it might be hard to find "thugs" willing to sign up for a certain mangling. And, of course, it's always possible a student will crack under real-world testing and end up maimed or worse — not exactly the kind of publicity a dojo wants.

To avoid such scenarios, a number of the martial arts developed a testing regime that includes board-breaking. Seen in this light, it makes perfect sense. Instead of hurting somebody else, hurt some lumber!

When training a beginner to break a board, a teacher focuses on helping his students to conquer their instinctive aversion to self-inflicted harm. Whacking a board as hard as we can with our bare hands just doesn't come naturally. And our fear of hurting ourselves in doing so is entirely justified. To break a board without breaking your hand, you have to do it just right, focusing your energy and hitting with enough force and follow-through (more on this later). Luckily, it turns out that even the tiny bones in your hand can handle a lot of stress — 40 times more than concrete, believe it or not [source: Newton's Apple].

Once students have mastered this initial phase, they can move on to the intermediate level in which they begin to increase the quantity of stuff they can break. The more they're expected to break, the more force and focus they require to accomplish their goal. Teachers must be vigilant during this phase as overconfident students can really injure their hands.

From there it's a matter of students continuing to train their energy and focus until they can break a giant stack of concrete blocks with a single blow. That's not a joke. People actually do that. In fact, board-breaking has taken on a life of its own, and there are now international competitions where adepts demonstrate astounding feats of concentration and power [source: Serrano].

But how do they do it?

How can hands break boards to pieces?

Strongman J.D. "Iceman" Anderson has appeared on several shows to demonstrate his icebreaking ability.
Strongman J.D. "Iceman" Anderson has appeared on several shows to demonstrate his icebreaking ability.
Eric Liebowitz/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Picture this: A man stands on a platform above a stack of seven massive slabs of ice, each one weighing nearly 300 pounds (136 kilograms). Putting his hands behind his head, he suddenly bends his upper body down to the top slab and touches it with his forehead. He repeats this process several times until, on the last bend, he follows through and hammers his skull into the slab. Incredibly, all seven blocks of ice break in half and fall to the ground.

This really happened. Strongman J.D. Anderson, aka the Iceman, smashed 2,000 pounds (907 kilograms) of ice to pieces with his head on "The Tonight Show with Jay Leno." That's extreme, and not recommended (see How Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy Works), but it demonstrates how phenomenally powerful the body can become given training and focus.

Advertisement

Breaking boards with your bare hand is a simpler feat than the one described above, and less potentially injurious (although your hand is a precious thing, too, and should be treated accordingly — more on that later). Typically, beginners start with a single board, roughly 1 foot (30 centimeters) wide. The material is usually pine, which is a softwood that breaks much more easily than a resilient hardwood like oak. The board should also be free of knots.

There are a wide range of techniques students can use, such as "hammer fist" (bringing your clenched fist down), "palm heel" (striking with the heel of your palm) and "knife hand" (the good old karate chop). Someone can hold the board, or it can be placed on supports. It should be held or supported on the sides, rather than the ends, allowing the practitioner to break the wood along its grain. Going against the grain, as the expression suggests, is much more difficult.

Regardless of what technique a practitioner uses to break a board, instructors usually emphasize preparedness through practice. Hitting a padded surface repeatedly helps increase accuracy, speed and strength while also toughening up the striking area of the hand or foot.

Mental preparation is as important as physical in this case. Hitting anything accurately requires focus. Practitioners work on their focus through breathing techniques, such as breathing out sharply or even shouting as they strike.

And when breaking a board, it's important to hit it as close to the center as possible. One of the key mental limitations that must be overcome is the body's natural instinct to slow down when approaching hard surfaces in order to avoid injury. Paradoxically, if your hand or foot slows down before hitting the board, the wood won't break, and if it doesn't break, the force of your blow will rebound into your hand and injure it. For this reason, instructors get their students to focus on hitting, not the board's surface, but a point a few inches beyond it. Imagining this point helps prevent the instinctive slow-down and ensures follow-through, which in turn helps transfer the full force of the blow to the board, breaking the wood instead of your hand or foot [source: American Martial Arts Academy].

That's all very well, but technique doesn't really explain how it's actually possible to smash apart hard objects with your soft, pliable extremities.

Board-breaking Physics

What great force you have!
What great force you have!
H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty Images

What exactly is a newton? No, not the tasty cookielike treat, but the unit of force. A newton, to be precise, is the amount of force it takes to shift a kilogram of stuff one meter [source: Merriam-Webster]. This also turns out to be roughly the same amount of force with which that celebrated apple supposedly clonked Isaac Newton on the head, inspiring his discovery of gravity. Coincidence? So they say. But that's a different story. The reason we're talking about the newton is because it's a useful way of measuring the force needed to break things like boards.

Back in the '70s, a couple of physicist martial artists decided to apply one of their passions to the other and did some research on board-breaking. How is it, they wondered, that we can lord over hard lumber with our puny hands and feet? Our big advantage, the thing we've got that that inanimate matter doesn't, is speed. And if we circle back to good old Newton (Isaac, not the cookielike treat or the unit of measurement), we might remember from our high school physics class that force equals mass times velocity. In other words, the faster you throw a punch, the harder it hits. But how much speed do you need?

Advertisement

The physicists found that a typical beginning practitioner of karate can work up a hand speed of 20 feet (6 meters) per second, which is just enough to break through a standard 1-inch (2.5-centimeter) piece of pine (students sometimes use reusable plastic training boards that are roughly the same dimensions and designed to break under the same amount of stress).

One of the physicists, Ron McNair (who later died aboard the space shuttle Challenger) was a black belt. It turned out he could get his karate chop going up to 46 feet (14 meters) per second, which means he could hit stuff with 2,800 newtons of force. If that doesn't sound impressive, consider this: It only takes 1,900 newtons to break a 1.5-inch (4-centimeter) thick concrete slab.

As mentioned on the previous page, speed isn't enough. Even speed and accuracy together aren't enough. Follow-through is crucial. And it's not just because we tend slow down out of fear of self-injury, it's because we tend to slow down no matter what. The reason for this was fathomed by yet another physicist martial artist who discovered that your hand reaches its top speed when it's 80 percent of the way through its strike. That's another reason why it's so important to aim your blow beyond the surface of the board.

Once a hand or foot makes contact with the board in just the right spot and with the necessary speed, the wood, like all material, will begin to oscillate until it just can't take it anymore. When material can't take any more oscillation, that means its elastic limits have been breached. Limits breached, with a loud sigh (snap), it surrenders (breaks) [source: Rist].

Thus, board-breaking is accomplished. But here's the big, looming question: Why do it? We learned earlier that proponents believe board-breaking is a useful gauge of progress, but is that really true? Is smashing lumber to pieces really a good idea?

Is board-breaking a good idea?

Is it worth it to teach our children how to break boards in karate class?
Is it worth it to teach our children how to break boards in karate class?
Spencer Jones/Photographer’s Choice/Getty Images

One ostensible reason for the promotion of board-breaking as an aspect of martial arts training is that it allows instructors to evaluate students' progress in a safe, controlled manner rather than throwing them into the ring with an opponent. But not everyone agrees with this. In fact, some instructors are vehemently opposed to board-breaking for a whole range of reasons.

One argument is that it's dangerous, especially for children. The human hand is an incredibly complex body part with 27 small bones, which allow for astonishing dexterity. Capable of phenomenally complex tasks like playing a violin, performing open-heart surgery or knitting miniature sweaters, the hand, skeptics argue, is not something we should fling repeatedly against hard objects. It's a body part we should safeguard for the future.

Advertisement

Breaking boards is hardly risk-free. Opponents point to cases in which young martial arts students have broken carpals, metacarpals and proximal phalanges (palm and finger bones). Should we really risk the hands of future musicians, truck drivers, doctors, sculptors or journalists?

Another objection to board-breaking (which often starts at the beginner level) is that it teaches children an unfortunate lesson: namely that performing meaningless stunts is praiseworthy. Ultimately, they say, board-breaking is useless in the real world. As the legendary Bruce Lee is supposed to have said, "Boards don't hit back." The point of martial arts isn't to be able to bust up a stack of pine, it's to be able to defend yourself from physical assault. To achieve that end, students should focus on enhancing their agility, speed, conditioning and technique.

Board-breaking skeptics argue that the real reason martial arts instructors like to use board-breaking isn't as a gauge of progress but rather as a visually impressive promotional stunt to attract more students [source: Salick].

No doubt some of these objections are valid. But the most compelling argument, that board-breaking is injurious, is hard to prove. While it's difficult to find statistics specifically related to board-breaking, numerous studies have been conducted on the safety of martial arts training. They all seem to indicate that while some practitioners do get hurt sometimes, the bulk of the injuries are minor bruises and cuts. Martial arts, according to the studies, are relatively safe, particularly karate [source: Zetaruk]. And since tameshiwari is such a common feature of karate training, it seems probable that breaking boards is pretty safe, too — as long as you practice and prepare.

Author's Note: How Board Breaking Works

Having only taken aikido, which emphasizes handholds rather than strikes, I've never broken a board with my bare hands. But maybe I'll take it up as a hobby (after having received proper instruction and training, of course!). I can see the cathartic appeal of it. Apparently some people like to prep their boards by baking them in the oven for a while. I think that'll be my approach as well — assemble a stack of boards, bake them until they're ready to snap in two if handled roughly and then karate chop one after the other until I've got enough kindling to start a fire in the woodstove.

Related Articles

More Great Links

Sources

  • American Martial Arts Academy. "Board Breaking." 2007. (Oct. 20, 2016) http://www.amaakarate.com/uploads/4/0/2/7/40272197/board_breaking_manual.pdf
  • Biryukov, A. "Karate Chop." Quantum. Vol. 9.5.Pages 14-18. May/June 1999. (Oct. 19, 2016) http://search.proquest.com/openview/b0a7b42fb324f98ba4328938d28ad444/1?pq-origsite=gscholar
  • Black Belt Magazine. "Pentjak Silat." (Oct. 19, 2016) http://www.blackbeltmag.com/category/pentjak-silat/
  • Chananie, Jon. "The Physics of Karate Strikes." Journal of How Things Work. Vol. 1. Fall 1999. (Oct. 19, 2016) https://www.free-ebooks.net/ebook/The-Physics-of-Karate-Strikes/html
  • Merriam-Webster. "Newton." (Oct. 21, 2016) http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/newton
  • Newton's Apple. "Karate." Twin Cities PBS. (Oct. 19, 2016) http://www.newtonsapple.tv/video.php?id=1297
  • Rist, Curtis. "How to Turn Your Fist Into a Block-Breaking Machine." Discover Magazine. Aug. 5, 2008. (Oct. 19, 2016) http://discovermagazine.com/2008/the-body/11-turn-your-fist-into-a-blocking-breaking-machine
  • Salick, Roger. "Board Breaking For Kids: A Parent's Guide." Salick's Karate & Martial Arts. 2011. (Oct. 19, 2016) http://www.salicks.com/site/view/74795_TheDarkSideofBoardBreaking.pml
  • Serrano, Drew. "The Art of Breaking." United States and World Breaking Association. (Oct. 19, 2016) http://www.usbawba.org/about5.aspx
  • Zetaruk, M. et al. "Injuries in martial arts: a comparison of five styles." British Journal of Sports Medicine. Vol. 39, No. 1. Pages 29-33. January 2005. (Oct. 23, 2016) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1725005/